How to Write Scene Transitions: Scene Breaks vs. Transition Paragraphs

Listen on: Apple Podcasts ↗  ·  Spotify ↗  ·  YouTube ↗  ·  RSS ↗

Your character finishes a tense conversation in her kitchen. She grabs her keys, walks out to the car, and drives across town to confront her sister. You stop typing and stare at the screen. Is that a new scene? Do you drop in a scene break? Do you start a new chapter? Or do you just keep writing? That’s a scene transition decision, and a lot of writers don’t give it the thought it deserves.

If you’ve been working with me for any length of time, you’ve heard me say it again and again: think in scenes. New location, new scene. New point of view, new scene. Jump forward in time, new scene. That’s good advice, and I stand by it, but it can leave you with a manuscript that reads like a string of hiccups, with a little row of asterisks every few pages, and a reader who never quite settles in.

There’s a reason for that. When we talk only about scenes, we’re only talking about half of what holds a book together.

In this article, you’ll learn:

  • The three ways to connect one scene to the next, and the effect each one has on your reader
  • How to decide between a hard scene break and a short transition sentence or paragraph
  • A five-minute exercise that shows you what scene transitions can do for your draft

Your Book Isn’t Just a Stack of Bricks

When I teach scene structure, I’m always saying things like “submit a scene to me for review.” On a recent First Draft office hours call, I noted: “That gives the impression that a book is just one brick piled on top of the other, but the reality is that’s not really how you build a wall.”

A real wall has bricks, and it has the spaces between the bricks. What fills those spaces? Mortar.

I want to give credit here. This metaphor came from Doug Kurtz, a writing coach who taught my program for a while when I was away recovering from surgery a couple years ago. I hadn’t thought about it this way before he brought up the metaphor, and I’ve been using it ever since. In this metaphor, the story is a wall, the scenes are the bricks, and the scene transitions are the mortar.

How you choose to mix that mortar changes the way the reader moves through your story.

First, Make Sure It’s Actually a New Scene

Before you decide how to connect two scenes, check that you actually have two scenes.

In my training on beats, scenes, sequences and acts, I define a scene as a story unit with a single location, a continuous, chronological period of time, a single point of view, and a single scene goal. Most of the time, if any of those four things change, you’re into a new scene.

But the scene goal is the one that can overrule the others. Think of the famous walk-and-talk scenes in The West Wing. The characters move from hallway to office to another hallway, but it’s one scene, because they’re still trying to win the same argument or deliver the same piece of news. As I put it in the training, “it’s ultimately that scene goal that’s providing unity to that scene.”

So if your character is still pursuing the same goal as she walks from the kitchen to the car, you may not need a break at all.

Three Types of Scene Transitions

If you really are moving from one scene to the next, you have three types of mortar to choose from.

1. The hard break

This is the one you probably already use. White space, a dinkus (those three asterisks, or an ornamental symbol of some kind), or a chapter break. It tells the reader: full stop, we’re somewhere else now.

I’ll be honest, this is my default. I write a lot of thriller and horror stories, and I like those hard stops, because I think they make for dramatic pauses and tension-filled moments. I bring the reader to the brink of something and then cut it off. The gun is pulled. Scene break. I grew up reading comic books, and I like that staccato rhythm.

But the staccato feeling is also a trade-off. A hard stop is more dramatic, but it can also feel choppy if you’re breaking every few pages, especially if nothing dramatic is happening.

2. The transition sentence or paragraph

Here, instead of a break, you write a sentence or two that carries the reader across the gap in time or place.

A scene ends at the grocery store. Then:

“As she drove home that afternoon, the rain poured down on the roof of the car, and it was late evening before she finally sat down to read the letter.”

We’ve gone from the grocery store scene to the letter-reading scene without a scene break. Instead, we used a transition sentence that describes the passage of time.

Often, it’s even shorter than that. It could be: “She hopped in the car, and within fifteen minutes she was back on the highway.” Or, “Two hours later, they finally got their pizza.” That’s it. That’s the whole transition, and it clearly reads much smoother than a hard scene break.

One warning: a transition is not a catch-up session. We still want to “come in late and leave early” for our scene writing. I see a lot of manuscripts where the writer opens with “After last night’s gunfight, she went home and had a rough night’s sleep. Waking up the next morning, she made herself a coffee…” We don’t need any of that. Good mortar is thin and efficient. One sentence that moves us forward in time or location, not a boring recap of what happened off page.

3. The transition scene

The third option is a small connector scene that breaks the usual rules. There’s no big scene goal, no major conflict, no big polarity shift. It just gets us from one scene to another.

The key is that the connector still must earn its place. If you’re going to have a little mortar scene between your bricks, a little transition connector scene, think about whether there is some important expository information you might be able to get across at that moment that still makes that moment feel important and worthwhile to the narrative.

If the connector scene drops a clue or develops a subplot, keep it. If your character is just thirsty and has a drink of water, consider cutting it.

How to Choose: Jarring or Smooth?

The technique you choose comes down to the effect you want to create.

If you are trying to create a more jarring effect, use that dinkus or hard scene break, whereas if you are trying to do something smoother, use those transition sentences and transition paragraphs to get us to the new scene.

Thrillers, horror and cliffhanger-heavy books tend to lend themselves to the hard stop. Journey stories, quieter character pieces, and long stretches of time passing tend to want the glide.

Whichever you lean toward, be consistent. I worked with a client recently whose books always handled time passing between scenes, never inside them. Then, three-quarters of the way through her second book, a big chunk of time passed in the middle of a scene. It jumped out and felt off-brand for the story. If you want to change how you handle time, do it on purpose, at a natural dividing line like the start of a new part of your book.

What This Looked Like for One Writer

A writer in my First Draft group coaching community was working on a novel that’s mostly one long journey. She’d taken my “new location, new scene” advice to heart, and then realized her entire book was turning out to be travel. That’s a lot of scene breaks.

Her first fix was to write a couple of 5,000-word scenes that covered three locations each. They felt too long, so she broke them up again. Then she did something smart. Between the pieces, she had her characters talk about where they were headed, or meet someone who mentioned where they’d been. That kept the big goal of reaching their destination in the reader’s mind.

What she’d discovered was the sequence.

A sequence is a group of scenes held together by a shared goal. Think of a sequence of scenes where your characters go on a date. You show them: getting ready, meeting up, dinner, the walk home, and then the kiss goodnight. Each scene has its own goal, but the sequence has the overarching goal of having a good date.

I spend much of my time saying “scene, scene, scene,” to my clients and students, but transitioning from scene to scene is its own technique, and it creates its own effect.

Try This

  1. Open your manuscript and find a scene break in the middle of a chapter: a dinkus, a row of asterisks, or a double space.
  2. Delete it.
  3. In its place, write one to three sentences that move the reader across the gap. Show time passing or the character moving from one place to the next. “Later that day” is a perfectly good start.
  4. Read the two scenes through, out loud if you can. Does it flow better? Or did you lose a dramatic pause you actually wanted?

Either answer is useful. Now you’re choosing your mortar instead of defaulting to it.

Scenes give your story its shape, but scene transitions decide how it feels to the reader to move through it.

If you’d like help figuring out the right rhythm for your draft, book a free call with a writing coach and we’ll look at your manuscript together. Or, take a look at my programs, including First Draft, where we work on this kind of craft every week.

About Kevin

Kevin T. Johns is a writing coach, editor, and author who helps genre fiction writers plan, draft, and finish their novels. He has published 10 books, hosts The Writing Coach Podcast (230+ episodes), and teaches a nuts-and-bolts method for turning an idea into a finished book.

Learn more about Kevin →  ·  See the coaching programs →  ·  Book a free call ↗

Find 5 More Hours Each Week for Your Writing

The Busy Writer Method by Kevin T. Johns: book cover of the free guide

Enter your info below to get the FREE guide: